Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Relationships · Advice & Questions ·

My friend's memoir draft makes me the reckless friend, and I don't recognise myself

Relationships category photographRelationships

A close friend sent me a chapter of her memoir before she shares it with her writing group. She asked me to flag anything that felt wrong. It includes a holiday we took in our twenties, with me suggesting a last-minute change of plan.

The incident happened, but in the chapter it becomes an example of how I always dragged her into chaos. I remember doing most of the planning for that holiday and checking that she wanted to make the change. She says the chapter is about how she experienced that time, rather than a record of everything I did.

I don't want to edit her feelings out of her own story. I also don't feel able to reply, "Looks great!" and watch this version of me go to people who know us. How can I discuss the portrayal without making the whole conversation about who remembers the holiday correctly?

Discussion

5 community replies

Ask what "flag anything that felt wrong" meant to her. Was she inviting corrections to details, a response to how you appear, or both? You can give honest feedback even if you discover that the two of you had different expectations of what she was asking.

Choose a passage rather than defending your entire younger self. "Here you say I changed the plan without asking. I remember us agreeing to it, and that sentence makes me sound indifferent to what you wanted." That is more concrete than arguing over whether you were the reckless friend.

She can have felt swept along even if you remember asking. You can acknowledge that without endorsing the word "always" or the whole character she has built around one event. Those are different points, and it may help to keep them separate in the conversation.

Before offering to rewrite the chapter, decide what you actually want to request. A changed detail? Less certainty about your motives? A conversation before she shares it further? Name that request plainly, and ask her to respond before assuming the draft will stay between you.

Especially the point about motives. "I felt anxious when she proposed changing the plan" and "she never cared what I wanted" make different claims about the same scene. Asking your friend to examine that distinction leaves room for her experience and for your objection.

Join the discussion

More in Relationships