Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Politics · Advice & Questions ·

My friend calls every voter on the other side stupid. How do I object without defending their choice?

Politics category photographPolitics

"They're all idiots," my friend said after a discussion of an election. I objected to the generalisation, and he asked which of the other party's policies I now wanted to defend.

I hadn't offered to defend any. I wanted to talk about decisions and their consequences without pretending that a single insult explains why everyone voted as they did. I also don't want a plea for respectful conversation to become a way of brushing aside the policies that upset him.

We usually enjoy talking about politics. Lately I either nod along or end up arguing about whether I am loyal enough to be in the conversation.

How can I challenge that habit while leaving room for a forceful disagreement about what the party stands for?

Discussion

5 community replies

You can keep the objection specific: the insult doesn't explain the vote or help you assess the policies. That doesn't require offering a defence of the party as the price of questioning the description of its voters.

Ask whether he wants to vent for a moment or examine the result with you. You may be willing to hear frustration without agreeing to spend the whole conversation repeating contempt.

I'd name the loyalty test too. If every objection to a generalisation becomes an accusation that you've changed sides, there isn't much space left for an honest discussion between friends.

I'd be wary of making "understand their reasons" sound like "their reasons excuse the consequences." Someone directly affected by a policy could hear that as being asked to set aside what it does.

That's worth making explicit. Understanding a reason doesn't decide whether it is sound or whether the policy is acceptable. You can keep the consequences in view and still refuse to use one insult as a complete account of every voter.

Join the discussion

More in Politics