Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Food · Advice & Questions ·

My established sourdough starter rose and then fell. Does that mean I ruined it?

Food category photographFood

A friend gave me some established sourdough starter and its feeding instructions. After feeding, I saw it rise up the jar. By the time I checked again that evening, it was lower, with a line showing where it had been. I'd expected success to mean it stayed at the highest level.

King Arthur's feeding trials describe a rise, peak and fall as the starter uses its food, with feeding ratio affecting the timing. That makes the falling level different from the failure I'd imagined.

How would you learn its routine without checking the jar constantly? I'm not asking for a contamination diagnosis from its height. I want to understand the cycle before planning a loaf around one photograph of a risen starter.

Discussion

5 community replies

The falling level alone isn't proof you've ruined it. The linked trials describe that cycle in an established starter. Continue with suitable maintenance instructions rather than treat one height reading as the whole assessment.

Mark the starting level when you feed and note a few observations. The line already showed you something useful: it had risen higher before you returned.

Record the feeding amounts and conditions along with the time. Otherwise tomorrow's different peak may look like another mystery even if you changed the feeding ratio or the room was warmer.

Would you first observe a feeding on a free day before committing to a workday bread schedule?

That would give you a useful reference without turning starter care into constant surveillance. Watch the cycle with the chosen routine, then plan conservatively. One observation day still won't promise an identical clock time for every future feeding.

Join the discussion

More in Food