Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Career / Work · Advice & Questions ·

My commission statement uses a new definition of a sale that nobody explained

Career / Work category photographCareer / Work

My quarterly commission statement excludes several orders I expected to count. When I asked why, my manager said only orders paid in full now qualify, rather than orders confirmed by the customer. That is different from the scheme document I was given at the start of the quarter.

I work in sales in England. I understand that the business wants to avoid paying commission on orders that fall through. But I had been tracking my work against the definition I knew, and some of the excluded customers are simply waiting for their normal payment date.

I haven't accused payroll of making an error or accepted the new calculation. What should I ask the company to clarify first: the figures, the scheme's wording or when the change supposedly took effect? I want an accurate answer about this quarter before the conversation turns into whether I support the business.

Discussion

5 community replies

Keep a copy of the scheme you received and request the revised version and effective date. Acas distinguishes contractual commission from discretionary schemes: contractual changes require the appropriate contract-change process, while discretionary changes should still be reasonable and clearly communicated. The label and terms matter; this account doesn't establish which rules apply to your scheme or what you are owed.

Ask for an order-by-order reconciliation showing why each expected payment was excluded. That will tell you whether the dispute is about a new rule, an incorrect payment status or both. You can check the arithmetic without agreeing that the new definition applies.

I'd acknowledge the business reason and keep it separate from timing: “I understand wanting completed payments to count. I'm asking which scheme governs the work already recorded this quarter.” That makes your question harder to turn into an argument about your attitude.

If the orders count next quarter once paid, might this just be a timing problem rather than money you've lost? I'd want that established before escalating.

Yes—ask whether they will count later, against which target and at which rate. A delay could affect more than one line on this statement, so don't assume the eventual outcome is equivalent. Once the calculation and terms are clear, you can decide whether it is resolved or needs further advice.

Join the discussion

More in Career / Work