Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Career / Work · Advice & Questions ·

My colleague thinks writing down her specialist process will make her replaceable

Career / Work category photographCareer / Work

I'm coordinating cover for a senior colleague's extended leave. She is the only person who knows how several unusual orders are handled. When I asked whether we could document the process together, she said that turning twenty years of judgment into a checklist would make it look as though anyone could do her job.

I wasn't trying to suggest that. I also can't ask the cover person to guess, or promise that we won't contact her while she's away without preparing properly. Our manager has said to get a manual finished, but hasn't allocated time for us to work on it.

How do I make this a useful handover without pretending every exception can be reduced to instructions? I'd like to acknowledge what she brings, but I can't honestly guarantee what the company will do with her role in the future.

Discussion

5 community replies

Start by separating repeatable steps from decisions that need experience. You might document the ordinary route, the signs that an order is unusual and who should decide in those cases. That respects the limits of a manual while giving the cover person somewhere reliable to start.

Ask the manager for actual handover time and an owner for the exceptions. “Get a manual finished” doesn't resolve who will make decisions during the leave. Your colleague shouldn't have to answer every uncertainty later because the team treated a document as complete cover.

I'd offer to do the first writing while she talks through a real example. Let her correct it and flag where the explanation depends on judgment. That could reveal the value of her expertise more clearly than either a blank template or a demand to write everything herself.

Would emphasising the judgment make her even more convinced the team can't cope without her? At some point you need a process other people can use.

Use the examples to identify which decisions others can learn, which need approval and which work may need to wait. Recognising limits doesn't mean accepting permanent dependence. It means asking the manager to organise cover around the actual work, rather than reassuring everyone that a checklist will settle it.

Join the discussion

More in Career / Work