Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Career / Work · Advice & Questions ·

My client wants me to pose as a buyer to obtain a competitor’s proposal

Career / Work category photographCareer / Work

A client asked me to research competing suppliers for a planning project. I expected to compare public information. Instead, they sent a made-up purchasing brief and asked me to contact a competitor as if I were genuinely looking to buy.

The competitor would be asked to prepare a tailored proposal and join a call. My client says this is ordinary market research and that I’m making too much of it. I haven’t contacted anyone yet. I’m willing to examine published offers or help commission clearly identified research, but I’m uncomfortable inventing a project so someone spends time selling to a buyer who doesn’t exist.

How would you explain the boundary without pretending I can make a legal ruling about the request? I want to offer a useful alternative, while being clear that I’m not prepared to make that call under a false story.

Discussion

5 community replies

Name the action you are declining: presenting the invented brief as a real purchasing opportunity. “I can compare public material and research options openly, but I won’t pose as a buyer for this proposal.” That is clearer than debating whether every form of competitor research is acceptable.

What information does the client actually need? A list of publicly advertised services may answer the planning question. A bespoke solution from a rival is a different request. Establish the gap before offering another research method, or you could spend time solving a problem the client has not defined.

The time cost to the competitor is part of why this feels different. They would be preparing for a sale that the caller knows cannot happen. You can explain that concern in ordinary terms without calling the client a criminal or pretending to know every rule governing their industry.

I would be comfortable comparing a competitor’s published prices or asking an openly framed question about an offer. The information might inform another business’s plans; that alone would not be the boundary for me.

Public comparison and an honestly framed enquiry leave room for the supplier to decide what to share. This brief asks the researcher to invent a buyer and a project to obtain tailored work. The boundary can be that specific. If the client insists, decline that part of the assignment and clarify what research you are still offering.

Join the discussion

More in Career / Work