Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Career / Work · Advice & Questions ·

My best employee wants a promotion I don't have available

Career / Work category photographCareer / Work

One of my team has asked what she needs to do to be promoted this year. She's doing excellent work and has started helping colleagues with difficult cases. I would like to support her, but there is no approved senior vacancy in our team and I don't control the headcount budget.

My predecessor apparently told her that if she kept performing, something would be found. She has asked whether I can confirm that. I can't. I also don't want to give her a list of extra duties that sounds like a route to promotion when it might only make her busier.

We still need a conversation about her development. How can I make it useful while being honest about the vacancy problem? Should I actively help her look at other teams, even though losing her would leave a real gap here?

Discussion

5 community replies

Say clearly what you can confirm, what you can ask for and what has no approval. She deserves to know that another set of stretch duties won't itself create a vacancy. You can advocate for her without converting your advocacy into a promise.

Ask what she wants from the promotion: a different kind of work, pay, authority or a recognised level. Those answers could point to different opportunities. Don't offer a course as a substitute for the thing she actually asked about unless she sees value in it.

I would help her understand other internal roles if that's what she wants. You can acknowledge the gap her departure would create while treating that as your staffing problem to plan for. Otherwise “development support” risks meaning support only while she stays in your team.

Is it fair to start that conversation before you've tried properly to get a senior post approved? You might send her away when there is a case worth making for a role here.

Make the case if the work warrants it, with a date for an honest update. At the same time, let her decide whether to explore other options. She shouldn't have to suspend her search because you're pursuing an approval you can't guarantee. Those two conversations can happen together.

Join the discussion

More in Career / Work