Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Politics · Advice & Questions ·

Must I volunteer to run a civic project before I can ask the group to consider it?

Politics category photographPolitics

I suggested that our neighbourhood association try a daytime session for residents who cannot attend evening discussions. The chair replied, “Good idea—bring us a full plan and commit to running it, then we’ll put it on the agenda.”

I can explain the problem and help with a short trial, but I can’t become the permanent organiser. The chair says everyone is stretched and ideas without owners just create more work. I understand that. Still, the rule seems to give people with spare time a stronger voice in deciding what the association even discusses.

Is it reasonable to ask for the need to be considered before anyone commits to delivering a solution? What is a fair amount of work for a proposer to bring when the existing schedule is the very thing they struggle to access?

Discussion

5 community replies

Offer the information you can reasonably supply: who the current time excludes, what a small trial would test, and what help you can actually give. Don’t quietly accept a permanent role to get the item heard.

The chair’s capacity concern is real. Considering the need can still end with “we cannot staff this now.” Hearing an idea shouldn’t be confused with approving or resourcing it.

I’d ask whether all proposals face that requirement, including ones brought by established committee members. An unwritten rule applied only to newcomers is harder to defend.

If nobody is willing to run the session, wouldn’t agenda time just create expectations the association cannot meet?

Put a limited decision on the agenda: whether the access problem is worth exploring and what information is missing. State openly that delivery isn’t promised. That lets the group recognise a need without pretending a volunteer has already appeared.

Join the discussion

More in Politics