Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Politics · Advice & Questions ·

Must I summarise the opposing view to its author's satisfaction before criticising it?

Politics category photographPolitics

Our politics reading group has introduced a rule: before criticising someone's proposal, you must summarise it until they agree you've understood it. I like the aim. Last time, though, one member kept rejecting summaries because none included all the reasons they thought their plan was best.

We spent most of the session trying to get permission to disagree. A brief restatement could catch real misunderstanding, but I don't think the person proposing something should have unlimited control over when criticism begins.

Would you keep the rule with a time limit, or make restating the argument an invitation rather than a condition? I'd like people to feel heard without making disagreement depend on winning their approval first.

Discussion

5 community replies

A useful restatement identifies the proposal and its main reason. It doesn't need to sound persuasive to the person who proposed it.

I'd allow one correction for a concrete misunderstanding, then move on. A participant could say, 'I understand that is your intended benefit; I disagree that the plan would deliver it.'

The rule may be compensating for a real problem in the group. Before removing it, ask whether people were previously criticising positions nobody had taken.

I wouldn't abandon it after one difficult session. A short limit and a moderator might preserve the useful discipline without letting a single speaker hold the floor.

That seems worth trying if the moderator can end the restatement stage. Make clear that acknowledging an accurate summary isn't agreeing with the criticism that follows. Otherwise the proposer still has a reason to withhold approval indefinitely.

Join the discussion

More in Politics