Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Neighbours · Advice & Questions ·

Must I explain my family situation to keep my phone at a phone-free supper?

Neighbours category photographNeighbours

A neighbour is hosting a small supper and has asked everyone to leave their phones in a basket by the door. She wants a few hours of proper conversation. I like that idea and am happy to keep my screen away during the meal.

That evening I need to be reachable for a time-sensitive family update. I asked whether I could keep my phone in my pocket and step outside if contacted. She said exceptions make the whole idea pointless and asked what could be so urgent. I don't want to share the family details with the table or turn dinner into an explanation of them.

I haven't agreed to attend yet. Would it be reasonable to say that I can manage no casual phone use but can't leave my phone in the basket, and bow out if that doesn't work for her? I don't want her to feel I am daring her to disinvite me.

Discussion

5 community replies

Yes. Tell her before the evening that you would enjoy coming but need to keep the phone with you. If she wants to keep the basket rule, decline warmly. Sorting it out now gives both of you a choice without a confrontation at her door.

The host's wish for an attentive table is reasonable too. Make your offer specific: the phone stays out of sight, and you leave the room to deal with the update. She can decide whether that fits the evening she wants to host.

I wouldn't provide increasingly intimate details until you reach whatever threshold counts as urgent to her. You have explained the practical need. Keeping some family information private doesn't make the need less real.

Could you attend for a shorter part of the evening, if there is a period when you don't need to be reachable? That might preserve the visit and her plan, but only if the timing actually works for you.

Only if that period exists. The post doesn't say the update can be timed around dinner, so I wouldn't offer a compromise you can't keep. Declining this supper can be a complete, friendly answer without becoming a dispute about phones in general.

Join the discussion

More in Neighbours