Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Politics · Advice & Questions ·

Must every political chart start its vertical axis at zero?

Politics category photographPolitics

For a discussion exercise, I drew a line chart using made-up figures to show a small change across several months. I clearly labelled the figures as illustrative, but I started the vertical axis above zero. A friend said that alone made the chart dishonest. When I redrew it from zero, the movement became difficult to see.

The ONS guidance on axes treats chart types differently: bars encode quantities through their length from a baseline, while a line chart can sometimes use a narrower scale to show variation. That doesn’t settle whether my particular presentation gives a fair impression.

Would you show both scales in a civic workshop, or choose one and explain it? I want participants to notice how presentation changes emphasis without teaching them that any non-zero axis proves deception.

Discussion

5 community replies

For this exercise, showing both seems useful. Keep the same illustrative data and time span, then ask what becomes easier or harder to see. The purpose is to inspect the choice itself.

A visible axis label isn’t the whole story. Your title and narration can still exaggerate a small movement. Check whether the words match the size of the change as well as its direction.

I’d explicitly say why this is a line chart. Otherwise someone may leave the workshop applying its scale choice to a bar chart, where the length is doing a different job.

If you show two versions, aren’t you telling participants both are equally suitable for every purpose?

Only if you leave out the purpose. Ask which view helps compare the level and which helps inspect variation, then discuss what context each needs. Two versions can reveal a trade-off without making them universally interchangeable.

Join the discussion

More in Politics