Must every political chart start its vertical axis at zero?
PoliticsFor a discussion exercise, I drew a line chart using made-up figures to show a small change across several months. I clearly labelled the figures as illustrative, but I started the vertical axis above zero. A friend said that alone made the chart dishonest. When I redrew it from zero, the movement became difficult to see.
The ONS guidance on axes treats chart types differently: bars encode quantities through their length from a baseline, while a line chart can sometimes use a narrower scale to show variation. That doesn’t settle whether my particular presentation gives a fair impression.
Would you show both scales in a civic workshop, or choose one and explain it? I want participants to notice how presentation changes emphasis without teaching them that any non-zero axis proves deception.