Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Politics · Advice & Questions ·

Must every live chat message go straight onto the screen at our civic forum?

Politics category photographPolitics

We promised online participants that their questions would be visible in the hall at our next civic forum. The proposed setup puts the whole incoming chat on the big screen. Nobody would read it before it appeared.

I'm worried about a personal insult or someone's phone number reaching the screen before our volunteer operator can remove it. The organiser thinks a review queue would let us quietly bury awkward criticism. That concern isn't imaginary either: the same small team would choose what gets shown and decide which questions the speaker answers.

Would you keep the display promise by showing reviewed questions, or withdraw it and have the facilitator read them aloud? I want remote participants to be heard without making everyone in the hall part of an unreviewed feed.

Discussion

5 community replies

Who is available to read the queue while the event is running? A promise to review messages isn't much use if the only operator is also handling the sound, slides and connection.

I'd be comfortable with a short review before display if the same content rules applied to questions handed in on paper. Criticism of the proposal should survive that check even when it is uncomfortable for the organisers.

Could the screen show the next few accepted questions rather than just the one selected for an answer? People could see that an awkward question had arrived without every incoming message going straight into the room.

I'd want a reason whenever a question is withheld. Otherwise participants are being asked to trust the very people their question may criticise.

A reason helps, but it needn't mean publishing the withheld text. Tell the sender whether the issue was personal information, an insult or something else, and give them a way to resubmit the actual policy question.

Join the discussion

More in Politics