Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Politics · Advice & Questions ·

Is the cheaper meeting room still cheaper if members have to travel farther?

Politics category photographPolitics

Our civic association can save on room hire by moving its monthly meeting to a hall at the edge of town. The treasurer calls it an obvious saving. Several members say the extra journey would cost them more and turn a short evening meeting into a much longer outing.

Nobody has compared the two locations beyond the association's hire bill. I'd like to include members' travel time and likely out-of-pocket costs, but those won't appear in our accounts and will differ from person to person. How would you compare the options without inventing one supposedly precise total for everyone's inconvenience—or treating costs outside the group budget as though they don't count?

Discussion

5 community replies

Keep two views of the decision: what the association pays and what attending requires of members. They don't have to collapse into one number for both to matter.

The cheaper hire might still be the right choice if the alternative is cancelling meetings. Ask the treasurer what the saving makes possible, rather than discussing it as a benefit with no purpose.

Find out who could no longer attend, not just whose journey becomes mildly longer. An average extra journey could hide a much bigger barrier for a few members.

Rotating halls looks fairer to me. It would share the longer journey instead of leaving the same people to absorb it every month.

Possibly, but check what rotation would do to bookings and people's ability to remember where to go. It shares the location burden only if members can use both venues at least some of the time; it doesn't automatically solve an attendance barrier.

Join the discussion

More in Politics