Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Food · Advice & Questions ·

Is scoring chestnuts before roasting just a peeling trick I can skip?

Food category photographFood

I bought edible chestnuts from a grocer for a soup. The roasting instructions start with scoring each shell, and I was tempted to skip it because I'm peeling them afterwards anyway. My friend thought the cuts were only there to make peeling easier.

Michigan State University Extension's chestnut guide says scoring lets steam escape and helps prevent the nuts bursting during roasting. I haven't heated them, and I'm keeping that preparation step.

If I don't want the work of preparing fresh chestnuts, would you switch to a soup recipe using a suitable prepared product? I like the idea of the soup more than I like the idea of making every ingredient a project.

Discussion

5 community replies

The source gives the cuts a purpose during roasting, before peeling begins. Waiting to remove the shell afterwards doesn't address that purpose.

Follow a clear preparation method with suitable tools. If scoring the nuts isn't a task you can carry out confidently, choosing another form of the ingredient is more useful than rushing it.

Tell your friend you found an explanation for the step you nearly skipped. You can change the plan without turning it into a contest about who knew more about chestnuts.

Would ready-cooked, peeled chestnuts make more sense if the soup is what you actually want?

Yes, if they're suitable for the recipe you choose. Read what that product needs rather than apply the fresh, in-shell roasting directions to it. Buying a prepared ingredient can keep the project at the size you intended.

Join the discussion

More in Food