Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Politics · Advice & Questions ·

Is official council business outside FOI if it was sent from a personal email account?

Politics category photographPolitics

I'm drafting a request about an English council's change to its appointment-booking service. A friend says there's no point mentioning relevant messages outside council email because a personal account is automatically outside freedom-of-information rules. Another wants me to demand an official's entire private inbox. Neither seems a sensible description of what I'm trying to find.

The ICO's guidance on official information in non-corporate channels explains that information held on a public authority's behalf may fall within FOIA even in a private account. The content and context matter. Purely non-official information isn't covered on that basis, and information within scope may still be exempt from disclosure.

I don't know which channels were used. I want records about this service decision, not unrelated personal conversations. How would you describe the subject and period clearly enough for a useful request, without assuming either that all private-account material is excluded or that a public role makes the whole inbox public?

Discussion

5 community replies

Keep the request anchored to the appointment-service decision and a relevant date range. The question about where records are held can sit behind that scope; it doesn't have to become a request for every message anyone sent.

An official's personal or party conversation isn't automatically council business just because of their job. The ICO guidance makes the content and context important, which is a useful boundary for both of your friends.

I'd ask for clarification if the council treats the account label as the whole answer. That is different from assuming a particular record exists or that it must be released.

If you don't know which channels were used, I wouldn't list a dozen messaging products. That could distract from the records you actually want.

Agreed on avoiding a speculative list. You can still make clear that the request concerns relevant official information held on the council's behalf, regardless of channel. That keeps the subject narrow while addressing the assumption that a personal account settles the issue.

Join the discussion

More in Politics