Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Relationships · Advice & Questions ·

Is my advice being ignored if someone asks for it and then chooses differently?

Relationships category photographRelationships

My friend spent an hour talking to me about whether to take on a volunteer role. I thought it would crowd out things she'd said she wanted time for, and I explained why. The next morning she texted, "I've decided to say yes. Thanks for helping me think!"

I felt unexpectedly irritated. Part of me thought that if she'd already wanted yes, she could have spared me the long discussion. But she says talking it through did help, even though she didn't choose the answer I favoured.

How do I tell the difference between being used as an audience and offering advice someone is free not to follow? I want to be helpful without treating my time as something that must be repaid by agreement. I also don't want every ordinary decision to become an evening of analysis.

Discussion

5 community replies

Her message says you helped her think, which may be exactly what she wanted. Your reasons against the role could have clarified what she was willing to give up for it. A different decision doesn't by itself establish that she ignored the conversation.

Ask what she found useful if you're genuinely curious, not as a demand that she defend the yes. You may learn whether she wanted alternatives, questions, reassurance or a sounding board. That could help you decide what sort of conversation you're willing to offer next time.

The time limit is a separate issue. You can say you have twenty minutes for a decision chat without requiring the person to choose correctly afterwards. Try setting the limit before you become invested in delivering an answer that makes the hour feel worthwhile.

Be clear when your own resources are part of the proposed plan. Advice about her volunteer role is her choice; an expectation that you will then cover tasks for her would need a separate agreement. Don't let those two things quietly merge.

That distinction would keep your advice from becoming a hidden vote over her decision. You can be interested in how it goes without offering extra help you don't want to give. Her freedom to choose and your freedom to limit your involvement can both remain visible.

Join the discussion

More in Relationships