Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Politics · Advice & Questions ·

Is Jersey part of the UK because it is a Crown Dependency?

Politics category photographPolitics

For a political map in our discussion notes, I put Jersey inside the UK category. When someone asked which Westminster constituency covered it, I realised I'd treated 'Crown Dependency' as another way of saying part of the United Kingdom.

The House of Commons Library briefing on Crown Dependencies says they are self-governing dependencies of the Crown, are not part of the UK and aren't represented in the UK Parliament. It identifies Jersey as one of them.

I can correct the category, but I don't want the new label to imply that Jersey has no constitutional relationship with the UK. Would a separate Crown Dependencies category, with a short explanation, be clearer than trying to fit every relationship under a single 'British' heading?

Discussion

5 community replies

Use the separate category. The shared constitutional connection doesn't make the two labels interchangeable.

I'd correct the Westminster question explicitly too: the briefing says the Crown Dependencies aren't represented in the UK Parliament. Otherwise someone may keep looking for a constituency that your map has led them to expect.

The map's key should say what it classifies. Geography, constitutional status and cultural descriptions aren't necessarily the same exercise.

Too many categories can make a small map hard to read. Could you just add a note beside Jersey rather than redesigning the whole thing?

A clear note could be enough if it actually removes Jersey from the UK category. The point isn't to multiply labels for their own sake; it's to stop the existing heading making a claim the map's source doesn't support.

Join the discussion

More in Politics