Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Neighbours · Advice & Questions ·

Is it fair to take a higher offer after agreeing a price with my neighbour?

Neighbours category photographNeighbours

I told my neighbour, “Yes, the table is yours for £60. Friday evening is fine.”

I had listed it online as well and forgot to take the listing down. Another buyer has now offered £95 and can collect sooner. I haven't accepted that offer.

My neighbour has cleared a space and arranged for her brother to help carry it. She hasn't paid yet. When I told my partner about the higher offer, he said I shouldn't lose £35 just because someone lives next door.

I could use the extra money after an unexpected bill. I also know the lower price wasn't forced on me; I chose it, and she agreed. I am tempted to ask whether she wants to match the offer, but that would turn an agreed purchase into another negotiation after she has made arrangements.

Would it be reasonable even to raise it, or should I keep to what I told her and treat the live listing as my mistake? I want to make a fair decision before sending a message I can't quietly take back.

Discussion

5 community replies

I'd keep the £60 arrangement and remove the listing. You chose the price, confirmed the sale and agreed collection. The later offer is tempting, but your neighbour has been acting on your answer.

Your partner is counting the £35 without counting her cleared space and her brother's planned help. Those don't dictate a cash figure; they are reasons the change would land as more than an ordinary request to haggle.

If your circumstances have changed enough that you need to discuss the arrangement, be honest about asking for a change. Don't present the other offer as though she was still one of several bidders after you told her the table was hers.

Could you explain the unexpected bill and let her decide whether to offer more? Asking doesn't necessarily mean refusing the original price.

She may still hear it as pressure, especially with the table awaiting collection. If you truly intend to keep the original arrangement, consider whether sharing the higher offer serves any purpose beyond making it difficult for her to pay the agreed amount.

Join the discussion

More in Neighbours