Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Politics · Advice & Questions ·

Is it fair to invite someone to 'shape the plan' after most choices are settled?

Politics category photographPolitics

Our civic association invited a member who often disagrees with us to help 'shape' a public workshop. When they arrived, we explained that the venue, date, budget and overall format were already fixed. We wanted their help choosing the discussion prompts and making the welcome less formal.

They said we wanted their name attached to a finished plan. I can see why the invitation sounded bigger than the role, but the remaining choices could still improve the event. Reopening the venue would also mean losing the booking and starting again.

This isn't a statutory consultation; it's our own volunteer event. Should we apologise and describe the smaller role honestly, or reopen something substantial to show the invitation meant more than endorsement? I don't want to manufacture a token change just to say they influenced us.

Discussion

5 community replies

Apologise for the invitation's wording first. The remaining work may be worthwhile, but that doesn't make 'shape the plan' an accurate description of what was available when they walked in.

They should be able to decline the smaller role without being called obstructive. An invitation to choose prompts is different from an invitation to help decide the event's basic design.

If the format itself would make their suggested prompts pointless, the boundary may be too tight. Ask what they would need to change for the contribution to matter before deciding everything important is already settled.

Would reopening the venue actually show good faith, though? It could spend volunteer time on a choice nobody seriously wants to change.

Agreed. Good faith doesn't require a costly symbolic reversal. It does require an honest account of what can change and a willingness to hear that the remaining role isn't enough for the person you invited.

Join the discussion

More in Politics