Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Food · Advice & Questions ·

Is icing sugar just another name for caster sugar in a sponge-cake recipe?

Food category photographFood

The sponge recipe calls for caster sugar. I have icing sugar and ordinary granulated sugar, and nearly chose the icing sugar simply because it feels finer. My sister thought caster might just be another regional name for the same powder.

King Arthur's sugar guide identifies caster as superfine granulated sugar and icing sugar as confectioners' sugar, a different powdered form commonly containing an anti-clumping ingredient.

How would you choose a sensible option before mixing? I'd rather understand the names and my recipe's needs than buy another packet unnecessarily or assume every finely ground sugar can do the same job.

Discussion

5 community replies

The guide separates those names: caster is superfine granulated sugar; icing or confectioners' sugar is a powder. The fact that both feel fine doesn't make them the same ingredient.

Check the actual icing-sugar packet too. Don't treat a general explanation as a complete ingredient list for every brand or product.

If this cake is for an occasion where you want the written result, use the specified ingredient or an adaptation you have a reason to trust. You can explore other sugars without making that occasion the deadline.

Could the granulated sugar be a closer alternative than the icing sugar?

The guide lists granulated sugar as a possible substitute for caster by weight, with finer grinding where appropriate. Consider the particular recipe and equipment instructions; it isn't a promise that every change will give an identical sponge.

Join the discussion

More in Food