Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Food · Advice & Questions ·

Is arriving empty-handed rude when the dinner host specifically asked us not to bring food?

Food category photographFood

Our friend invited us for dinner and wrote, 'Please don't bring food or wine; I've got the menu covered and no spare fridge space.' I was happy to follow that, but my mum says turning up without something is rude and I should at least take a cake.

I understand the wish to contribute. I'd also be annoyed if I made a clear request and someone arrived with another course for me to fit in. I don't want my friend to have to thank me while finding room for a gift she asked us not to bring.

How would you handle the pull between the hospitality custom you grew up with and this particular host's request?

Discussion

5 community replies

Follow the request you were actually given. You can arrive warmly, thank her for dinner and be an attentive guest without adding another item to her menu.

Tell your mum the host specifically mentioned space and food. You don't have to persuade her to change her own hosting customs before deciding how you'll respond to this invitation.

If you want to offer help, make it something she can comfortably decline. Don't turn 'I appreciate this' into another task she has to assign you.

What if I'd already baked a cake before the host sent that message?

Then make another plan for the cake and follow the new information. Having already done the baking doesn't oblige the host to absorb it into dinner. You can be disappointed about the timing without making that her problem.

Join the discussion

More in Food