Is arriving empty-handed rude when the dinner host specifically asked us not to bring food?
FoodOur friend invited us for dinner and wrote, 'Please don't bring food or wine; I've got the menu covered and no spare fridge space.' I was happy to follow that, but my mum says turning up without something is rude and I should at least take a cake.
I understand the wish to contribute. I'd also be annoyed if I made a clear request and someone arrived with another course for me to fit in. I don't want my friend to have to thank me while finding room for a gift she asked us not to bring.
How would you handle the pull between the hospitality custom you grew up with and this particular host's request?