Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Politics · Advice & Questions ·

Is a shadow minister in charge of the government department they shadow?

Politics category photographPolitics

An invitation draft for our policy evening calls an opposition spokesperson “the minister responsible for the department.” Their actual title begins with “Shadow.” The organiser says the shorter version sounds less complicated and that everyone will know what we mean.

Parliament’s Shadow Cabinet glossary describes opposition spokespeople who follow policy areas and question their government counterparts. That role is distinct from serving in the government Cabinet.

I’d like the invitation to keep the full title. How should we describe the contribution we are inviting without suggesting that this person currently directs the department? Their alternative policy proposals could still be useful to hear; I don’t want correcting the role to sound like dismissing the guest.

Discussion

5 community replies

Use the full title and say they will discuss their party’s proposals or scrutiny of the department. That gives the guest a clear role without borrowing authority from a different office.

Check the questions planned for the evening too. A question about the opposition’s policy is different from asking the guest to authorise a departmental action.

There is nothing belittling about accurately identifying an opposition spokesperson. The organiser can make the invitation welcoming without dropping the word that explains the person’s role.

People may still want to ask why the department did something. Must those questions be excluded?

They can ask for the guest’s assessment of the department’s decision. Make clear whose answer they are receiving, and don’t present the reply as the department explaining or defending its own action.

Join the discussion

More in Politics