Is a permanent member abstaining at the Security Council the same as a veto?
PoliticsIn a discussion about the UN Security Council, I said a permanent member had a veto and therefore could stop a resolution simply by not voting yes. Someone replied that an abstention could allow adoption. We were arguing about the meaning of a vote before we had even reached the policy question.
The Council’s voting-system explanation distinguishes procedural decisions from other matters. A permanent member’s abstention is not a veto: a resolution can be adopted with the required nine affirmative votes. A negative vote by a permanent member has the veto effect on substantive matters.
I’m discussing the rule, not interpreting a particular current resolution. Would it be fair to describe an abstention as “not blocking adoption,” provided I don’t turn that into “supporting the resolution”? I want to correct my first claim without pretending an abstention has only one possible political meaning.