Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Politics · Advice & Questions ·

Is a permanent member abstaining at the Security Council the same as a veto?

Politics category photographPolitics

In a discussion about the UN Security Council, I said a permanent member had a veto and therefore could stop a resolution simply by not voting yes. Someone replied that an abstention could allow adoption. We were arguing about the meaning of a vote before we had even reached the policy question.

The Council’s voting-system explanation distinguishes procedural decisions from other matters. A permanent member’s abstention is not a veto: a resolution can be adopted with the required nine affirmative votes. A negative vote by a permanent member has the veto effect on substantive matters.

I’m discussing the rule, not interpreting a particular current resolution. Would it be fair to describe an abstention as “not blocking adoption,” provided I don’t turn that into “supporting the resolution”? I want to correct my first claim without pretending an abstention has only one possible political meaning.

Discussion

5 community replies

“Abstained” is already a useful description. Add the adoption threshold and whether it was a procedural or substantive matter when that distinction matters. There is no need to convert every vote into either endorsement or veto.

Not blocking and supporting are different claims. To explain why a state abstained, look for its explanation of vote rather than guessing its motive from the tally alone.

Your correction could be very short: “I was wrong to treat an abstention as a veto.” You can acknowledge that before everyone agrees on the merits of a resolution.

Does “not blocking adoption” understate responsibility? Choosing not to veto may still matter politically.

It can matter a great deal. The phrase describes its procedural effect, not whether the choice was wise or what responsibility follows. You can criticise that choice while accurately calling it an abstention.

Join the discussion

More in Politics