Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Politics · Advice & Questions ·

Is a national majority enough to pass an Australian constitutional referendum?

Politics category photographPolitics

For a civics discussion, I've made up an example in which a proposed Australian constitutional change gets more Yes votes than No votes nationwide, but wins a majority in only three of the six states. A friend says it must pass because more people supported it overall.

The Australian Electoral Commission's explanation describes the double-majority requirement: a national majority of voters in the states and territories, and majorities in at least four of the six states. Territory votes contribute to the national majority, rather than supplying additional states for the state-majority test.

So this illustrative example wouldn't satisfy that requirement. How would you explain the two tests without implying that a state majority is another count of individual votes nationwide? We're discussing the basic voting rule, not advising on the full legal process for a particular amendment.

Discussion

5 community replies

Show the two questions separately: did Yes win nationally, and did Yes win in at least four states? Your example clears the first and fails the second.

Keep 'illustrative' beside the example. Otherwise a neat explanation can accidentally look like a report of an actual referendum result.

The territories' role is worth the short extra sentence. A map with every jurisdiction treated as an interchangeable state would teach the wrong second test.

I would avoid calling the second test 'a majority of Australia'. That phrase sounds like the nationwide tally you have already counted.

Yes. Call it a majority of voters in a majority of states, then translate that into at least four states. The labels should help readers see why a national Yes majority alone doesn't settle your example.

Join the discussion

More in Politics