Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Politics · Advice & Questions ·

If the US Senate consents to a treaty, is ratification already finished?

Politics category photographPolitics

Our international-affairs group's note says a treaty is fully ratified as soon as the US Senate approves it. I want to check that before we use the note to explain when an agreement takes effect.

The Senate's guide to treaties distinguishes its approval of a resolution of ratification from ratification itself. The Senate gives its advice and consent; describing that important step does not establish that every later step has happened.

Would you use 'the Senate consented to ratification' in a short explanation, or is that too obscure without another sentence? One member thinks correcting the term makes the Senate's decision sound merely advisory and unimportant. I think we can recognise its significance without declaring the whole process complete.

Discussion

5 community replies

'The Senate consented to ratification' seems a useful description of the decision you have identified. I'd then say what later action the record shows, rather than assume it has happened.

The Senate's consent is a substantial constitutional step. I'd explain what it authorises rather than describe 'advice and consent' as an informal recommendation.

Which agreement and which stage does your note actually document? A report of the Senate vote may answer the consent question without answering the separate question about when the agreement takes effect.

A short public note can't explain every stage of treaty-making. I'd worry about correcting one term by adding a paragraph that loses the reader.

You may only need one extra sentence: the Senate has given its consent, and the note hasn't established completion of ratification. That keeps the limit visible without trying to reproduce the entire procedure.

Join the discussion

More in Politics