Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Food · Advice & Questions ·

If I make a darker roux, will it thicken my gravy more strongly?

Food category photographFood

I want a darker gravy and thought cooking the flour-and-fat roux further might give me both deeper colour and more thickening. My friend described a dark roux as the stronger version. I haven't begun cooking.

The recipe I was going to use starts with a pale roux. I'm considering taking it further, but I don't know whether the same amount will still thicken the liquid as the recipe expects. I've been using stronger to mean both a more pronounced flavour and a thicker sauce.

How would you choose the method when you care about both colour and body? I'd like to understand that change before I start adjusting a pan of gravy by guesswork.

Discussion

5 community replies

The sauces chapter of Professional Cooking explains that heavily browned roux has less thickening power than white roux, while contributing flavour and colour. A more pronounced flavour isn't the same thing as a greater ability to thicken a given amount of liquid.

Use a gravy formula intended for the roux stage you want. Don't turn a general comparison in the textbook into your own fixed conversion between every pale and dark roux.

Tell your friend which result you're aiming for before cooking together. Otherwise one of you may be watching the colour while the other expects the same sauce thickness from unchanged proportions.

Could you keep the pale-roux recipe for now and try a brown-roux gravy with a different meal?

That would give each method a clearer purpose. Make the first gravy as written, then choose a full brown-roux method when you want to explore that flavour. You don't need one pan to answer both questions today.

Join the discussion

More in Food