Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Confessions · Advice & Questions ·

I won a sewing machine, and my family decided it should go to my cousin

Confessions category photographConfessions

At a work raffle I won a sewing machine I'd love to use. Mum immediately said it was perfect timing because my cousin's old machine had broken.

At the next family lunch she told my cousin I'd “come to the rescue”. I laughed instead of correcting her. My cousin thanked me, looking surprised.

I haven't offered the machine to anyone. I can see why it would help her, but I had been excited about learning on it myself. Now keeping it feels like taking away a gift she's been told to expect.

Do I speak to Mum first or tell my cousin directly? I don't want to make my cousin sound grasping when she never asked, and I don't want to give it away simply because my silence has made the correction awkward.

Discussion

5 community replies

Tell your cousin promptly that there was a misunderstanding and you hadn't offered the machine. Make clear you know she didn't ask. Otherwise she may start planning around an expectation you are still leaving intact.

Speak to your mum too: she made an offer involving something you hadn't agreed to give, and you failed to correct it. Those are separate contributions to the misunderstanding; you don't need to claim either person created it alone.

You can care about your cousin's disappointment without promising another machine or taking responsibility for solving the broken one. An alternative offer should be something you actually want to make, not a new payment for permission to keep the prize.

Would it be kinder to give it to her anyway if she will use it immediately and the narrator is only hoping to learn? There is a plausible generous choice here, even if it shouldn't be assumed.

There is, and the narrator can choose it freely. But immediate use isn't a reason the family can announce that decision for them. Correct the expectation first so any later offer isn't simply surrender to a gift that was already promised in their name.

Join the discussion

More in Confessions