Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Confessions · Advice & Questions ·

I wanted a stricter game rule only after the loose one cost me the win

Confessions category photographConfessions

Two other players made a trade, and I called it unfair. Earlier that evening I'd benefited from a similar trade and said it was all part of the game.

We were using a casual arrangement we'd never defined very clearly. I do think a clearer limit could make the next game better. I also know I discovered this urgent concern at the exact moment someone else won.

My friend said we could discuss it before playing again. I kept arguing as though his win needed to be suspended until I was satisfied.

How do I propose the change without pretending my motive was pure principle? I'd like to be able to lose an evening's game and still raise a fair question about the next one.

Discussion

5 community replies

Accept the result under the arrangement you all used that evening, including when it helped you. Then propose a clearer agreement before the next game. The timing is part of why your friends heard the objection as an attempt to recover the win.

You don't need a perfectly disinterested motive to notice an unclear rule. Admit that losing made you care more, and let the group assess the proposed change separately from that admission.

Describe the limit you want consistently. Would it also exclude the earlier trade that benefited you? If not, you may still be designing a rule around the particular outcome rather than the problem you say you noticed.

Your friend already offered a time to discuss it. Taking that offer would let everyone consider the next game without defending the result of this one. You can stop arguing now without pretending the question was ridiculous.

At that later discussion, leave room for the group to prefer the looser arrangement. Raising a fair question doesn't guarantee your preferred rule. Decide whether you want to play on those terms rather than keeping the last result under review.

Join the discussion

More in Confessions