Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Career / Work · Advice & Questions ·

I've been asked to mediate a project dispute I already have a view on

Career / Work category photographCareer / Work

Our director asked me to “be the neutral person” in a meeting between marketing and operations about a launch date.

I control part of the project budget, and I've already recommended the later date because of the staffing needed. Marketing doesn't know I've given that recommendation. I can help the teams compare the options, but I can't honestly arrive as someone with no stake or prior view.

I haven't accepted the meeting role yet. How do I explain the conflict without sounding unwilling to help? I want to be clear whether I'm chairing a decision discussion, contributing my own position or being asked to provide an independent perspective.

Discussion

5 community replies

Tell the director about the prior recommendation before accepting the “neutral” description. Ask what the meeting is meant to achieve and what role they need from you. Your budget responsibility is relevant information, not an embarrassing detail to hide until someone notices.

You can help run a useful discussion while acknowledging that you have a position. For example, separate the time when each team explains its constraints from the time when you contribute the budget facts and your recommendation. Don't let the chair's seat quietly make your preferred date the default.

The teams also need to know who can decide the launch date and what constraints that person will weigh. A meeting can feel unsuccessful if everyone thinks it must end in unanimous agreement when the actual next step is a decision by the director.

If everyone with a stake has to step aside, a small organisation may have nobody left to lead the conversation.

Having a stake doesn't mean you cannot contribute or chair. It means the role should be described honestly. If the director wants an independent perspective, ask for someone unconnected to the decision; if they want a structured project discussion, agree that role and disclose your involvement to the participants.

Join the discussion

More in Career / Work