Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Confessions · Advice & Questions ·

I used an AI answer as a referee after giving it only my side of the argument

Confessions category photographConfessions

I showed my partner a paragraph from a chat tool and said, 'Even a neutral view thinks my request is reasonable.' My partner asked what I'd told it.

I'd described my frustration about our weekend plans in detail. I'd left out the earlier agreement I'd changed and the practical objection my partner had raised. The answer reflected a situation that was much cleaner for me than the conversation we'd actually had.

I wasn't looking for help understanding both sides. I wanted an outside-sounding voice to make my position harder to disagree with. When my partner asked to see the prompt, I said the exact wording wasn't the point. It was very much the point.

How do I own that without making the whole conversation about whether chat tools are useful? I still have a real preference about the weekend. I need to stop presenting my edited account as independent evidence that my partner should accept it.

Discussion

5 community replies

Withdraw the claim that the paragraph settled the disagreement. Tell your partner what you omitted from the prompt. Your preference can still be discussed, but the outside-sounding wording doesn't give the omitted agreement less weight.

NIST's generative-AI risk profile identifies human over-reliance on AI systems as a risk. That is general risk guidance, not an assessment of your relationship or proof that a particular output is wrong. Here, your own account already explains the incomplete input.

The useful question isn't whether another prompt could produce a verdict in your partner's favour. That would keep the tool in the referee role. Return to the agreement you changed and the objection you hadn't included.

You could use a writing aid to organise your own thoughts without presenting its response as an independent witness. If you do that, be clear about what you supplied and leave your partner free to disagree with the resulting framing.

Changing that role also means not asking the tool to evaluate your apology and then bringing back another certificate. Explain the editing you did, hear your partner's account and discuss the actual weekend. No generated endorsement needs to be the final participant.

Join the discussion

More in Confessions