Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Confessions · Advice & Questions ·

I told the waiter my partner wasn't having dessert before she could answer

Confessions category photographConfessions

The waiter asked about dessert and I said, “We're being good tonight.” My partner was still looking at the menu.

She ordered the pudding she wanted. On the way home she asked why I'd made her choice sound like breaking a rule we'd agreed on. We hadn't agreed on one. I'd decided I didn't want dessert and liked presenting that as a shared plan.

I said it was only a figure of speech. But I also know I would have felt pleased if she'd put the menu down after I said it.

How do I apologise without turning it into another conversation about what either of us should eat? I don't want to replace answering for her with a performance of giving permission. She never needed that from me.

Discussion

5 community replies

The menu question was addressed to her too, and you supplied an answer that made your preference sound shared. “I spoke for you and added a judgment you hadn't agreed to” gets closer than apologising for an unfortunate phrase.

Don't make a point of encouraging her to order dessert next time. That could keep you in the role of approving the choice. Let her answer the waiter and decide what she wants without your commentary.

You can choose no pudding for yourself. The awkward part is the little “we” that recruited her, followed by “good” making disagreement sound like a lapse. Neither word was needed to order what you wanted.

Would it be reasonable to ask whether she wants you to avoid comments about food altogether? Couples can have different ideas about teasing, and a broader conversation might help.

Ask what bothered her, but don't turn this clear incident into a search for a rule she failed to provide. She has already explained that you answered for her and implied an agreement. Own that before asking her to design your future dinner conversation.

Join the discussion

More in Confessions