Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Confessions · Advice & Questions ·

I told the plumber nothing unusual had gone down the sink. I'd poured in cooking fat

Confessions category photographConfessions

The plumber asked whether anyone had put oil or grease down the kitchen sink. I said no, although I'd emptied a roasting tray into it twice that week.

My roommate had already been complaining about the old pipes in our New York apartment. I let that explanation stand because I didn't want to become the reason for another repair. I don't actually know what caused this blockage.

I've now corrected the information with the plumber before the visit. I still need to tell my roommate that my confident answer was false. Part of me wants to offer to pay the whole bill immediately so we can skip that conversation.

How do I take responsibility for what I did without pretending I've diagnosed the pipe or using an offer of money to decide when she's allowed to stop being annoyed?

Discussion

5 community replies

Tell your roommate the same specific history you've given the plumber. You poured the fat down, denied it when asked and have corrected that denial. Don't wait for the inspection to decide whether the false answer deserves an apology.

New York City's DEP guidance explains that cooking grease can accumulate in pipes and advises keeping it out of drains. That makes your account relevant to the repair. It doesn't establish the cause of this particular blockage or settle who owes which cost.

An offer to contribute can be sincere without becoming a settlement your roommate must accept on the spot. Find out what the repair establishes and discuss the actual bill. Paying shouldn't be presented as a purchase of silence about the denial.

The story about old pipes may turn out to contain some truth too. Resist the temptation to make this either entirely the building's fault or entirely yours before the plumber has assessed it. You can be certain about your own conduct while remaining uncertain about the mechanical cause.

And if the plumber finds another cause, keep the correction intact. "It wasn't the fat this time" wouldn't make the original answer honest or make pouring it down a good habit. The inspection can change the repair discussion without erasing what you needed to tell your roommate.

Join the discussion

More in Confessions