Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Confessions · Advice & Questions ·

I told the family Dad wanted no funeral speeches. He'd never said that

Confessions category photographConfessions

My sister put away the page she'd written when I said Dad had wanted no speeches. I had no conversation or note to support that. I was afraid of listening to speeches and crying in front of everyone.

The funeral hasn't happened yet. We had discussed a few arrangements with Dad, but this wasn't one of them. I took my own wish for a quiet service and gave it the authority of something nobody could ask him about.

Now my sister has told our aunt there won't be an opportunity to speak. I need to correct this while there's still time to discuss the service.

How do I tell them without making my difficulty with speeches the new reason everyone must agree? I don't want the correction to turn into a demand that I prove my grief by sitting through whatever anyone proposes.

Discussion

5 community replies

Tell your sister and aunt that the no-speeches instruction was yours, not Dad's. Do that before debating the programme. They need the false attribution withdrawn so they can take part in a discussion that hasn't already been settled by a wish you invented.

Being frightened of hearing speeches is something you can say honestly. It doesn't need to be disguised as Dad's preference to deserve consideration. You can ask for a manageable format while recognising that other people also have something they want to say.

Don't replace the invented instruction with a confident guess about what he would probably have wanted. Separate any arrangements he actually discussed from the choices now being made by the family. Uncertainty is more honest than supplying another version of his voice.

Your sister had already written a page. Ask whether she still wants to use it, rather than assuming that reopening the programme obliges her to deliver it after all. She shouldn't have to become the person who publicly resolves your correction.

And if she does want to speak, discuss the setting with her rather than asking her to persuade you that you can bear it. You might agree on length or another moment for memories, but let those be proposals the people involved can consider, not a replacement rule announced in Dad's name.

Join the discussion

More in Confessions