I told someone she wasn't a real fan because she found the story through the film
ConfessionsShe mentioned her favourite scene from the adaptation. I asked whether she'd even read the books.
When she said not yet, I told her she wasn't really a fan. I have shelves of the series and years of conversations about it. For some reason, her arriving through a two-hour film felt like she was claiming the same thing without doing the time.
She wasn't claiming my history. She was saying she'd enjoyed a scene.
Do I owe her an apology beyond retiring the phrase "real fan"? I don't want to overcorrect by pretending the books and film are identical. I want to stop making my enjoyment into an entrance requirement for hers.