Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Confessions · Advice & Questions ·

I told someone she wasn't a real fan because she found the story through the film

Confessions category photographConfessions

She mentioned her favourite scene from the adaptation. I asked whether she'd even read the books.

When she said not yet, I told her she wasn't really a fan. I have shelves of the series and years of conversations about it. For some reason, her arriving through a two-hour film felt like she was claiming the same thing without doing the time.

She wasn't claiming my history. She was saying she'd enjoyed a scene.

Do I owe her an apology beyond retiring the phrase "real fan"? I don't want to overcorrect by pretending the books and film are identical. I want to stop making my enjoyment into an entrance requirement for hers.

Discussion

5 community replies

Apologise for telling her what her enjoyment was allowed to count as. You can still love the books and prefer them. The part to withdraw is making her route into the story a reason she shouldn't get to discuss it.

Reading the books may give you details she doesn't know. That can make for an interesting conversation if she wants one; it doesn't make her response to a film scene invalid.

Ask what she liked about the scene, if you genuinely want to know. Don't turn the next exchange into a generous-looking quiz that gives her another chance to qualify. She already supplied a perfectly usable opening for talking together.

Your years with the series remain yours even if new people join the conversation. You don't need to establish that she has less history in order for your own history to matter. That competition was something you introduced, not a claim she made.

And welcoming her doesn't require you to become her guide to every volume. You can enjoy one conversation about the film without assigning either of you a role. The alternative to gatekeeping is ordinary interest, not compulsory mentoring.

Join the discussion

More in Confessions