Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Politics · Advice & Questions ·

I suggested an idea at my first civic meeting. They said they'd tried it years ago

Politics category photographPolitics

I suggested a residents' information stand at the weekly market. Before I'd finished, someone said, "We tried that." Two other people nodded and the meeting moved on.

I joined the civic group recently. I don't know whether the old stand drew no interest, cost too much, or simply lost the person who organised it. Long-standing members have already spent evenings on ideas that didn't work, and I can understand not wanting to relive all of them for each newcomer.

Still, I can't learn from an experience whose conclusion is the only part I'm allowed to hear. I also don't want to assume an unwritten history is worthless just because it isn't in the papers I received.

What is a reasonable way to ask what happened before, without making the older members defend their whole record or treating my version as new merely because I wasn't there?

Discussion

5 community replies

A small question might reopen this productively: what did the earlier stand try to achieve, and why did it stop? Those answers could tell you whether your suggestion repeats the same problem or differs in a relevant way.

Go into that conversation prepared to drop the idea if the old experience answers it. Asking for context works better if it isn't just the opening move in insisting they try again.

The meeting may also need a better way to orient new members. A brief note about previous projects and lessons could save everyone time, including the people currently doing the explaining.

Could you offer to put together that note after a short conversation with someone who remembers? That would turn your request into something other newcomers could use.

That's a practical offer, provided the person agrees and the work stays manageable. Mark what is recollection and what records support it, and let them check the account. You don't need to produce a definitive history before the group can explain why one idea ended.

Join the discussion

More in Politics