Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Politics · Advice & Questions ·

I submitted an anonymous civic project idea and was later asked to score the entries. Should I disclose it?

Politics category photographPolitics

I sent an idea to our civic association's anonymous call for small projects. A month later, the organiser asked me to join the panel that will score all the entries. They don't know which one is mine. There is no payment or prize for the author, but I care about seeing that project selected.

The organiser says anonymity will keep the scoring fair. I can recognise my own proposal, though, and I also know why some of its rougher details were written that way. We have very few volunteers, so stepping off the panel would leave work for someone else.

Should I tell the organiser privately and ask for a different role? I'm reluctant to reveal authorship to the whole panel if that undermines the anonymous process, but staying quiet feels like using anonymity for a purpose it wasn't designed to serve.

Discussion

5 community replies

Tell the organiser before you see or score the entries. The anonymity protects authors from being judged by identity; it doesn't stop an author recognising and favouring their own work.

You can disclose the conflict without announcing the proposal's identity to every scorer. Ask the organiser how to manage it under the process they advertised.

Don't assume skipping only your own entry solves everything. If projects compete for one slot, the marks you give the others could affect your proposal's chances too. The organiser needs to consider the whole scoring role.

Losing a volunteer entirely seems wasteful. Checking cost estimates without giving preference scores could be a useful separate job.

That could work if the checking task is narrow and handled consistently, with someone else reviewing your proposal. It still needs the organiser's agreement. Quietly switching hats yourself would leave the conflict hidden and the responsibilities unclear.

Join the discussion

More in Politics