Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Confessions · Advice & Questions ·

I shared a secret, then acted as though my friend owed me one back

Confessions category photographConfessions

"You know something really private about me now," I said. "Surely you can tell me something."

My friend had listened kindly while I talked about a family worry. She didn't change the subject or dismiss it. She just didn't offer a private revelation of her own. I started asking questions, then accused her of keeping me at a distance when she said she'd rather not answer.

I do want friendships where openness goes both ways. But I chose what to share, and I hadn't told her she was accepting a trade by listening.

How do I apologise without pretending I don't care about mutual closeness? I want to be able to say I sometimes feel exposed, rather than make her prove affection by handing over something she'd preferred to keep private.

Discussion

5 community replies

Take back the claim that listening created a debt. You can say you felt exposed after sharing and responded by pressing her. That tells her what happened without making the feeling a reason she should have answered.

Openness can look different in two people. She stayed with your difficult subject and treated it kindly; that is part of the exchange too. It doesn't settle whether the friendship gives you everything you want, but it deserves a place in your account of how she responded.

You can choose to share less next time if that feels more comfortable. Let that be a decision about your own privacy, rather than a punishment announced to make her disclose more. She should still be able to trust the confidence you've already placed with her.

What sort of closeness are you actually missing: knowing more about her life, getting time together or hearing that she cares? A secret may not provide the thing you want. A more specific request could give her something she can freely consider.

And let her answer that request in her own way. She might welcome more time together and still keep the same private matters private. The conversation would be more useful if different kinds of care could count, rather than every route leading back to the revelation you first demanded.

Join the discussion

More in Confessions