Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Confessions · Advice & Questions ·

I shared a friend's messages after hiding her name. People still recognised her

Confessions category photographConfessions

"Isn't that the woman making the red quilt for the exhibition?" someone wrote beneath my post. I'd covered my friend's name and photograph. I'd left the quilt, the exhibition and her own description of the argument visible.

We'd disagreed about how to finish a joint project. I posted a screenshot in a public craft group because I wanted outside opinions. I didn't ask her. When she found it, I defended myself by saying nobody knew who she was.

Now someone apparently does. I've removed my post, but I can't tell her who saw it or whether anyone kept it. I also don't want to repeat the identifying details while trying to explain the mistake.

What should I tell her now? I still want somewhere to talk through disagreements. I need to stop treating a hidden name as permission to publish the other person's words.

Discussion

5 community replies

Tell her where you shared it, what you left visible, that someone connected it to her and that you've removed your post. "I thought it was anonymous" explains your assumption; it doesn't answer her concern now that you know the assumption failed. Be clear about what you can't establish.

The ICO's anonymisation guidance explains that identification can depend on contextual details, not just names. That supports the narrow privacy point here; it doesn't establish your legal position. The quilt and exhibition gave this audience a connection that covering the profile picture didn't remove.

Seeking advice about your own conduct can be reasonable. Posting the actual conversation adds her wording and context to that request without her agreement. You could discuss how you handled a disagreement with someone you trust, using only the detail needed, rather than asking a public group to judge her messages.

Would a correction in the craft group help her, or make more people look for the original? Don't choose a public apology simply because it feels more substantial. Ask her whether there's a useful step you can take there without naming her or restating the clues.

That distinction matters. If she wants a correction, agree its wording and audience before posting it. If she doesn't, accepting that choice doesn't make the apology smaller. You can own the disclosure directly with her without creating a second public account of the argument.

Join the discussion

More in Confessions