I say the team social is optional, then treat people who skip it as less committed
ConfessionsI wrote "not fully engaged with the team" in a draft appraisal. The example in my head was that this colleague never comes to our Thursday pub evening.
I'm the team manager. I introduce the evening as optional, and I've never made attendance a work objective. This colleague meets deadlines, helps others during the day and has given me no reason to call the work disengaged. I seem to be using enthusiasm for an event I enjoy as evidence of enthusiasm for the job.
The appraisal hasn't been shared. How do I correct the assessment and the expectation I've created? Simply deleting the sentence would improve the draft, but it wouldn't answer why I keep telling people they can freely decline while privately counting their absence.