Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Confessions · Advice & Questions ·

I say the team social is optional, then treat people who skip it as less committed

Confessions category photographConfessions

I wrote "not fully engaged with the team" in a draft appraisal. The example in my head was that this colleague never comes to our Thursday pub evening.

I'm the team manager. I introduce the evening as optional, and I've never made attendance a work objective. This colleague meets deadlines, helps others during the day and has given me no reason to call the work disengaged. I seem to be using enthusiasm for an event I enjoy as evidence of enthusiasm for the job.

The appraisal hasn't been shared. How do I correct the assessment and the expectation I've created? Simply deleting the sentence would improve the draft, but it wouldn't answer why I keep telling people they can freely decline while privately counting their absence.

Discussion

5 community replies

Remove the unsupported assessment before sharing the draft, and examine the rest of the review for the same assumption. You describe useful work contributions that you've discounted because the colleague doesn't join a pub evening. Those actual contributions belong in your assessment.

Acas guidance on reviews and appraisals discusses agreed objectives, behaviour at work and objectives relevant to the job. That offers a useful basis for reviewing your evidence. It doesn't determine the legal position of this particular event or replace your organisation's appraisal process.

Don't ask this colleague to disclose why they don't attend so you can decide whether the reason is good enough. You've called the event optional. A private explanation shouldn't be the extra requirement that turns their absence into an acceptable one.

Your team may not immediately believe a fresh assurance that attendance doesn't matter. Make sure the choices you control actually match it, including who receives information and opportunities. A cheerful announcement won't help if useful work conversations still happen only over those drinks.

That needn't mean banning colleagues from talking about work socially. Bring decisions and information back into the channels the whole team can use. The practical change is that declining the pub shouldn't also mean having to reconstruct what happened to their work afterwards.

Join the discussion

More in Confessions