Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Confessions · Advice & Questions ·

I replaced my son's fish and let him think it was the same one

Confessions category photographConfessions

My son's fish died while he was away. I bought another that looked similar and told myself I'd spared him a sad homecoming.

Now he's noticed a different marking on its tail. He asked if it was a new fish. I said the light must be different.

He's ten. I haven't just delayed telling him about a pet dying; I've started asking him to doubt something he can see. I don't know why the first fish died, and I don't want to invent an explanation for that either.

How do I tell him now without making him responsible for reassuring me that I meant well? The new fish is staying. It just shouldn't have to keep performing the role of the old one.

Discussion

5 community replies

Tell him his observation was right. “The first fish died while you were away. I bought this one and wrongly said it was the same fish. You did notice a difference.” That corrects both the event and your answer about the tail.

You don't need a complete explanation of the death before acknowledging it. Saying you don't know is more honest than supplying another confident story to make the conversation easier.

Give him room to care about both fish. He doesn't have to reject the new one to prove he misses the old one, or welcome it immediately to make you feel the replacement was worthwhile.

Could you explain that you were trying to spare him sadness? I don't think a child needs to hear only a blunt account with no reason for the parent's choice.

You can explain the intention after the facts, without asking him to endorse it: “I didn't want you to be upset, but I shouldn't have hidden this.” Then listen. He may be sad about the fish, angry about the lie, both, or something else you haven't predicted.

Join the discussion

More in Confessions