Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Confessions · Advice & Questions ·

I regifted a vase to the friend who gave it to me, then denied it was the same one

Confessions category photographConfessions

My friend turned the vase over and said, “Isn't this the one I gave you?”

It was. I'd forgotten who it came from when I wrapped it for her birthday. Then I remembered the tiny mark underneath and said mine had only looked similar.

Regifting was one awkward moment. Now I've asked her to doubt her own present.

I haven't used the vase, and I don't want to pretend I treasured it. How do I correct the denial without delivering a second insult about how little I wanted the gift? It has already completed the return journey; I'd like the explanation to stop travelling.

Discussion

5 community replies

Tell her you remembered and panicked: “You're right, it was the vase you gave me. I forgot when I wrapped it, then recognised it and shouldn't have denied it.” That doesn't require a review of its suitability for your shelves.

The vase has managed a round trip without needing a new identity. Keep the explanation shorter than the attempt to establish that two identical marked vases somehow entered the friendship.

Let her decide what she wants to do with it now. Asking for it back so you can prove you'll display it would turn an unused gift into another performance neither of you wanted.

I'm not convinced regifting itself needs to be treated as a betrayal. People receive objects they won't use. The denial seems like the part that clearly needs correcting.

That's the distinction to keep. You can acknowledge that the birthday gesture was thoughtless and the denial dishonest without promising to keep every present forever. A separate, personally chosen birthday gesture could be kind, but it shouldn't be offered as a purchase of immediate forgiveness.

Join the discussion

More in Confessions