Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Confessions · Advice & Questions ·

I recognised my friend's anonymous competition entry and kept scoring it

Confessions category photographConfessions

I knew the opening line. My friend had read that poem to me weeks before it appeared among the anonymous entries I was helping judge.

This is a small local competition, and I'm one of three volunteer readers. The coordinator asked us to flag any entry we recognised. I didn't. I thought I could be fair, and I also wanted to be the person who helped my friend get noticed.

I've submitted my scores. No result has been announced. My friend's poem is near the top of my list, and I can no longer tell how much of that ranking is the poem and how much is my hope for her.

How do I tell the coordinator without implying my friend cheated? She didn't know I'd be reading entries. The failure to disclose was mine, and I'm afraid an attempt to repair it will land on her instead.

Discussion

5 community replies

Tell the coordinator now, before results are finalised. Identify the entry and explain that you recognised it before scoring. The stated process gave you a clear action, and you skipped it. Let the coordinator decide how to handle the affected score under that process.

Don't claim you can now prove you were unbiased by explaining every mark. You may have reasons for liking the poem and still have a connection that should have been disclosed. The immediate question is whether the assessment followed the arrangement, not whether your friend deserves to be talented.

Be explicit that your friend didn't know you were a reader, as far as you know. Don't turn your disclosure into speculation about why she entered that poem. You have information about your own decision; you don't have evidence of a plan on her part.

Avoid asking your friend to withdraw before you speak to the coordinator. That would make her absorb the consequence of a problem she didn't know about, while leaving the judging process uninformed. It would also give you another private way to alter the outcome.

And disclosure needn't automatically mean disqualification. That's for the organiser to decide from the rules and circumstances, not something you should promise or threaten. A fresh reader or another procedure might be available, but don't announce a remedy before the coordinator has considered it.

Join the discussion

More in Confessions