Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Confessions · Advice & Questions ·

I pushed my son to donate his favourite toy because I wanted him to seem generous

Confessions category photographConfessions

My son chose two toys for a donation bag. I pointed to his favourite truck and said giving something he really loved would mean more.

He said he wanted to keep it. I kept talking about other children until he put it in the bag and went quiet. When I praised his generosity, he asked whether he could take it back or whether that would make him selfish.

The bag is still at home, and I've taken the truck out while we talk. I wanted to encourage kindness. I also liked the idea of being the parent whose child willingly gave away a favourite thing, except willing wasn't what had happened.

How do I correct that without making him comfort me about being a bad parent? I don't want the lesson he has to demonstrate next to be forgiving me on cue.

Discussion

5 community replies

Tell him clearly that he can keep the truck. He made a donation choice before you turned a favourite possession into a test. You can acknowledge the two toys he actually selected without ranking them as a lesser kind of kindness.

“I kept pushing after you said you wanted it, and that wasn't fair” names your action. “I was only trying to teach you generosity” could leave him still believing his reluctance was the problem.

You can involve him in choosing how the family helps without making affection for an object something he has to overcome for praise. The donation bag doesn't need to become evidence of what kind of child he is.

Would it be reasonable to discuss why giving matters at all? I'd be wary of concluding that parents should never encourage a child beyond the easiest choice.

That conversation is still possible. But it should leave an actual choice, rather than continuing until the parent gets the preferred sacrifice. Here he had already offered toys; the immediate repair is to withdraw the moral test you added, not demand a better explanation of why he loves the truck.

Join the discussion

More in Confessions