Real people. Real opinions.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Family · Advice & Questions ·

I promised to keep my sister's pregnancy news private. What can I say when Mum asks me directly?

Family category photographFamily

“You know something, don't you?” Mum asked when I wouldn't join her guessing about why my sister had cancelled a visit.

My sister told me she is pregnant and asked me not to share it yet. She wants to tell our parents herself. I agreed. Then, when Mum asked whether anything was wrong, I said, “Everything's fine,” although I only knew what my sister had chosen to tell me.

Mum now thinks I am shutting her out. My sister says, “Just say you don't know,” but I do know, and I don't want to make a false statement that becomes another family grievance later.

There is no emergency I know about. This is a question about who gets to announce personal news. How do I keep the confidence without dropping obvious hints or pretending I can certify that everything is fine?

Discussion

3 community replies

You can decline the guessing without explaining why: “If she has news to share, she'll tell you. I'm not going to speculate about her.” The wording won't guarantee Mum stops asking, but it doesn't announce the pregnancy or require you to say something you know is false.

Correct the reassurance separately if it comes up: “I shouldn't have spoken for how she's doing. You can ask her directly.” Your promise was to protect the news, not to provide a report on your sister's wellbeing. Don't expand the information you share while trying to repair that overstatement.

Tell your sister you will keep the confidence but won't claim not to know things. She may be trying to find the shortest escape from a difficult question. Agreeing on that limit now is kinder than discovering later that you both understood “keep it private” differently.

Join the discussion

More in Family