Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Neighbours · Advice & Questions ·

I promised to keep a neighbour's recipe private, then offered it for a booklet

Neighbours category photographNeighbours

A neighbour gave me her spice blend on the condition that I kept the recipe between us. I agreed. Months later, I offered to contribute my version of the dish to a small street recipe booklet. I've changed the vegetables, but the blend is still hers.

The editor has asked for the full recipe. Nothing has been printed. When I told my neighbour, she said she was happy for people to eat it, not for me to circulate the quantities.

I could contribute a different dish, but I'd already described this one enthusiastically and the editor is expecting it. Is asking my neighbour again reasonable, or would that put pressure on her to release something I already promised to keep private?

Discussion

5 community replies

She has answered the question you actually needed to ask. Choose a different recipe and tell the editor promptly. Being enthusiastic before checking didn't change your promise to her.

Don't offer a nearly identical blend with one quantity altered as a workaround. The point between you is what you agreed to keep private, rather than how little you can change while still getting the dish into print.

You don't need to tell the editor that your neighbour is being difficult. “I offered a recipe I didn't have permission to share; I'll replace it” owns the mistake and keeps her out of the dispute.

You might ask whether she'd enjoy contributing a different dish herself, but only if you can leave it as a real invitation. Don't make that the price of accepting her no about this blend.

I'd leave even that invitation until you've sorted your replacement. Otherwise it could sound like she now has to provide content to rescue a promise you made to the editor.

Join the discussion

More in Neighbours