Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Confessions · Advice & Questions ·

I promised my son fifteen dollars for a chore, then added conditions after he finished

Confessions category photographConfessions

My thirteen-year-old son stacked the last board game and asked for the fifteen dollars I'd offered. I said the boxes needed labels first.

I'd asked him to put loose pieces into the right boxes and organise the game cupboard. He did that. While checking it, I decided it would also be useful to wipe the shelves and make labels. When he said that wasn't the job, I told him he shouldn't expect payment for doing the bare minimum.

The "bare minimum" was exactly what I'd described. I can see that now. I also don't want to teach him that every ordinary bit of helping at home needs a price attached.

How do I correct this without turning the payment into another lecture? We can discuss regular household jobs separately. Today I used a bigger principle to avoid admitting I'd changed one small agreement.

Discussion

5 community replies

Pay the agreed fifteen dollars and acknowledge that he completed the task you described. You can say you were wrong to add labels afterwards. He doesn't need to first accept your wider view about family chores in order for you to keep this particular promise.

There's a distinction between a cupboard that wasn't sorted and a cupboard you now imagine improving further. Your account says he sorted it. Wanting cleaner shelves or labels is reasonable; using those new wishes to redefine whether he finished is the part to withdraw.

If you want some household tasks to be unpaid, have that conversation before the next offer. You can agree what belongs to ordinary shared upkeep and what you might separately pay for. This incident doesn't require you to settle the value of every future chore.

Would you have added the labels if you'd already handed over the money? That may help you identify whether you were improving the job or looking for a reason to delay paying. You don't need to tell him your entire thought process, but be honest with yourself about it.

And either answer still leaves the original agreement intact. Even a genuinely useful extra task can be a new request. "I noticed something else we could do" gives him a different conversation from "You haven't earned what I promised", which is how you presented it.

Join the discussion

More in Confessions