Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Confessions · Advice & Questions ·

I promised anonymous feedback, then started trying to identify the person who criticised me

Confessions category photographConfessions

The card said we spent too much of the craft session listening to me and not enough time making things. I began comparing the handwriting with names on the attendance sheet.

I run a small informal group and asked everyone to leave feedback without names. I said I wanted honest answers. This comment made me want to find the writer and explain how much preparation the sessions take.

I haven't approached anyone. I've drafted a message asking another member whether they recognise the handwriting.

How do I deal with wanting to defend myself without breaking the arrangement I offered? The comment may contain something useful about how I divide the time. I don't want to make the next session an exercise in discovering who dared to say it.

Discussion

5 community replies

Don't send the handwriting message. You offered a route for feedback without names, and the wish to defend yourself doesn't give you a new agreement with the writer. Keep the card as feedback about the session rather than a clue about a person.

There is a concrete issue you can examine without knowing the author: how much time is spent explaining and how much making. You can look at the next plan and decide whether the balance is the one you intended. That doesn't require accepting every implication of the comment about you.

One critical card doesn't establish that everyone feels the same, and anonymity doesn't make the observation either accurate or worthless. Consider the point about time in the session. You can check your own plan and invite further voluntary feedback without announcing a verdict about what the whole group thinks.

If you ask the group for more detail, make it a genuine invitation that doesn't require the original writer to identify themselves. You could ask what would help them get started sooner. A speech about how much work you do before asking would make that invitation harder to answer freely.

And if nobody adds more, don't turn the silence into another search for the person withholding an explanation. Consider the feedback you have and decide what change, if any, you want to try. Anonymous input can be incomplete without becoming something the contributor must step forward to defend.

Join the discussion

More in Confessions