Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Confessions · Advice & Questions ·

I praise my daughter for speaking up until she questions a decision I've made

Confessions category photographConfessions

I told my daughter to speak up when she disagreed with a decision at school. At home, when she asked whether she could save for a coat after I said we weren't buying another one, I snapped, "You always have an answer for everything."

She's fifteen. I don't want every household decision to become an endless negotiation. But her question wasn't an insult, and she hadn't refused the answer about what I would buy. She was asking whether there was another option.

Now she says speaking up seems to be something I admire only when I'm not the person hearing it.

How do I apologise without promising that every objection will change the decision? I want to explain limits and also make room for a question without treating the existence of the question as bad behaviour.

Discussion

5 community replies

Apologise for the dismissal and answer the question she actually asked. The spending decision and whether she can save towards a coat were two different questions. You don't have to give the same answer to both to recognise that she raised the second reasonably.

Being willing to hear a reason doesn't require agreeing with it. You can explain the limits you're setting, hear her response and sometimes keep the original decision. What undermines the conversation here is calling her argumentative before considering what she said.

Don't ask her to prove she's mature by never sounding disappointed. A respectful question can still come from someone who strongly wants another answer. Judge the words and behaviour in the exchange instead of treating visible investment in the outcome as a failure to listen.

You may need a way to bring a discussion to an end when it really has become repetitive. Agree what that looks like while you're calm. It should leave room for an initial question, rather than turning your first no into a rule that she cannot ask what it covers.

And use that endpoint consistently rather than only when her question exposes something you hadn't considered. You can say you need time to think about an option. Showing that an adult can revise or clarify an answer would fit the confidence you've encouraged her to use elsewhere.

Join the discussion

More in Confessions