Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Politics · Advice & Questions ·

I opposed the decision. Can I still approve the minutes as accurate?

Politics category photographPolitics

I voted against our civic association ending its Saturday drop-in sessions. The draft minutes give the result correctly and record my objection. Now the secretary wants committee members to reply 'I agree' beneath the whole document.

I don't dispute the record. I do worry about my reply being quoted later as agreement with the closure, particularly because the decision is already contentious. The secretary says I'm making a routine check unnecessarily difficult.

Would you reply that the minutes accurately record a decision you still oppose, or ask for the approval wording to change for everyone? I want the record settled without putting my name under a position I haven't changed.

Discussion

5 community replies

A short reply could do both jobs: 'I confirm this is an accurate record; my vote against the closure remains as recorded.' That addresses what the secretary needs without leaving your meaning to guesswork.

The fact that your objection is already recorded matters. If the minutes omitted it, this would be a different dispute. Here I'd start by confirming the accuracy you say you accept.

I'd prefer the standard request to say 'confirm accuracy' in future. It would spare the next dissenter this same exchange, without requiring a discussion about the closure every time minutes are circulated.

I can understand the secretary's irritation if this delays getting the record finished. At some point the association has to carry on with a decision even while members disagree.

Carrying on doesn't require an ambiguous reply, though. The qualified confirmation suggested here could settle the record immediately. I'd reserve any attempt to reopen the closure for a separate discussion rather than attaching it to approval of these minutes.

Join the discussion

More in Politics