Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Neighbours · Advice & Questions ·

I offered to serve the punch before learning my neighbour wants dry ice in every cup

Neighbours category photographNeighbours

“The cups need to be smoking when you hand them over,” my neighbour said while we planned a Halloween gathering in the US. I'd offered to pour the punch, but hadn't realised he wanted pieces of dry ice in guests' cups. Nothing has been bought or served.

I found FDA advice on dry ice in food and drinks. It warns against direct contact or consumption and says the material should have completely sublimated before service. I don't have training in handling it, and I don't want to judge whether each cup is ready.

He says I can just tell people not to swallow the pieces. Can I make my offer conditional on ordinary punch, or should agreeing to serve mean helping him work out the effect he wants?

Discussion

5 community replies

Agreeing to pour punch didn't include every method someone might later add. Tell him before he buys supplies that you can serve ordinary punch and won't hand out cups containing dry ice.

“Don't swallow the pieces” doesn't address the FDA's advice to ensure the dry ice has completely sublimated before service. Don't turn yourself into the person deciding, cup by cup, that an unfamiliar process is safe.

The visual effect matters to him, so acknowledge that rather than pretending you're offering exactly the same thing. You can still be firm about what you're willing and competent to serve.

If he drops the dry ice plan, accept that answer. There's no need to keep proving that the initial idea was wrong after you've agreed on a version you can help with.

Yes. Thank him for changing it and return to the practical plan for the punch. A settled disagreement doesn't need a second round in front of the guests.

Join the discussion

More in Neighbours